him to make false statements while he was in
custody.30
The case was concluded on January 24, 2013
in the Ankara 11th Assize Court. The court
convicted them for being “members of an
illegal organisation”and sentenced Taş to 10
years and 6 months, Kalaycı to 7 years and
6 months, and Hasan Anlar, Halil İbrahim
Vargün and Murat Vargün to 6 years and 3
months each in prison.31
The statement made by İHD concerning this
decision concluded that the lawyers were
punished for their professional activities and
their work as HRDs.32
30 Human Rights Defender Kalaycı Released (01.02.2010; Bianet):
https://m.bianet.org/english/print/119766-human-rights-defenderkalayci-released
31 Turkey: Sentencing of four lawyers members of IHD Ankara Branch
(05.02.2013; International Federation for Human Rights): https://www.
fidh.org/en/region/europe-central-asia/turkey/Turkey-Sentencing-offour-lawyers-12830
32 İnsan Hakları Savunuculuğu ve İHD’ye Baskılar (13.04.2020; Human
Rights Association), p. 26-27: https://www.ihd.org.tr/wp-content/
uploads/2020/04/20200413_IHDIHSBaskilarOzelRaporu.pdf
ASRIN CASE
Newroz Celebrations in Diyarbakır.
(Fotography: Nar Photos)
Direct and systematic interventions against lawyers started in 2011. The
46 lawyers of PKK leader Abdullah Öcalan, who is held in a prison on İmralı
Island, were taken into custody on November 22, 2011 in a synchronous
operation in various provinces. Prior to the operation, the lawyers had
been targeted through media outlets known for their close ties to the
government. Of the lawyers taken into custody, 36 of the 46 were arrested
on charges of “membership of a terrorist organisation” and “directing a
20
A DEFENSELESS DEFENSE
terrorist organisation.”33 Some of the lawyers who were released at intervals
remained in detention for 2.5 years. As in many subsequent cases, the
indictment rife with errors with respect to procedural and substantive law,
including the violation of attorney-client privileges.34 Even the interrogations
of the lawyers on trial were not conducted in line with procedures. Despite
violating the laws, the lawyers’ meetings with their client (Abdullah Öcalan)
33 70 Arrests in Istanbul and Diyarbakir (28.11.2010; Bianet): https://bianet.org/english/minorities/134338-70-arrests-inistanbul-and-diyarbakir
34 Turkey Joint letter for Turkish lawyers (16.07.2012; Lawyers for Lawyers): https://lawyersforlawyers.org/en/turkeyjoint-letter-for-turkish-lawyers/
ASRIN CASE
21